Words by: Natalia Godinez
Art by: Siena Thomas

Finding a definitive winner in the debate over whether movies are superior to their book counterparts can be challenging. I usually say the book is better, but after days of consideration and a few contestants, ‘The Princess Diaries‘ is the only exception. If you weren’t aware of the book’s existence, it’s likely because the movie outshone it.

While the book series by Meg Cabot holds a special place in many hearts, the 2001 movie adaptation transcends its source material in several compelling ways.

The setting is one of the most immediate and striking disparities between the movie adaptation and the book. Departing from the usual New York setting in the book and many other movies, chick flick director Garry Marshall took a bold step by situating the movie in San Francisco. The picturesque landscapes of the Californian city offer a refreshing backdrop, showcasing its landmarks such as the Golden Gate Bridge, the Painted Ladies, and its iconic hills.

Mia’s dad is a regular presence in the book series but the movie adaptation streamlines the narrative into a hero’s journey in the classic Disney trauma style. His absence in the movie serves as a catalyst for Mia’s emotional journey. This journey, as for anyone, revolves around Mia discovering herself and where she belongs in the world. At its heart, ‘The Princess Diaries‘ is a coming-of-age movie; romance is just a little spice for the plot. The themes that epitomise this genre, self-acceptance, personal growth and self-integrity are echoes of our collective journey as human beings.

In the book and in Anne Hathaway’s portrayal, Mia is a relatable and endearing protagonist, navigating the challenges of adolescence and unexpected royal responsibilities with awkwardness, wit and charm. Contrary to its book counterpart, Julie Andrews’ regal presence as Queen Clarisse Renaldi lends the movie an air of sophistication and nostalgia. While the characters in the book can’t stand each other, the movie’s sweet and complex relationship allows us to ponder on the bittersweetness of family bonds.

However, the movie could have been even more compelling had it preserved its original political discourse. Mia and her best friend Lilly maintain their environmental consciousness, yet the movie tones down certain facets of their political opinions. Which makes sense, considering it is a Disney Channel movie. After all, they wouldn’t want to risk turning it into a device to push political propaganda.

The movie also brings to life the opulence and grandeur of royalty in a way that words on a page cannot replicate. Mia’s Y2K x Modern European royalty outfits live rent-free in my head. Her style is unforgettable, from her signature Dr Martens and bucket hat to her breath-taking floral ballgown. Even her rock-climbing outfit slays! Costume designer Gary Jones served us looks that feel timeless and magical.

Like many great movies that achieve cult status, ‘The Princess Diaries’ boasts a memorable soundtrack. You can tell Whitney Houston co-produced the movie because only a musical mastermind could have curated such a heart-felt soundtrack as this. Whether it’s the infectious energy of tracks like ‘Miracles Happen’ by Myra or the emotional resonance of ‘A Summer Song’ by Chad & Jeremy, the soundtrack leaves an indelible mark on audiences long after the credits stop rolling.

While ‘The Princess Diaries’ book series is undoubtedly the blueprint, its cinematic adaptation takes the crown. The movie will always make me wish my long-lost grandmother whisked me away to my rightful place on a throne too. With its pleasing aesthetics, iconic performances, streamlined narrative and emotional resonance, the movie in its own right has become a timeless classic.

As Mia Thermopolis herself would surely agree, sometimes the key is to allow yourself to change for the better… whether it’s from ordinary girl to Princess of Genovia, or from a great book series to an unforgettable movie adaptation…